In the original routing, the hole played to the current chipping green next to the 1 st tee. Related Landscapes . The tee box location and angle of play to the green were almost exactly the same as today. Unfortunately, many alterations to the layout have been made down the years, including a new millennium renovation, eroding much of the original architect’s work. Seth Raynor. You Want in Best Store. The 12th hole is a Template hole known as a Biarritz, known for the swale you play through. Raynor then enticed you to look to the right side to play the hole, although the green better accepts shots hit from the left hand side of the hole. It’s only a 140 yard hole but accuracy is demanded. There is a large mound on the left side of our green that looks manufactured. Thanks for taking “A Position”. Sharing a tee with the current 12th hole, it played across the back of the driving range fairway and to number 1 approach, where the green used to lie. One of the better short holes you’ll play, its green complex is one of the best on property. I can attest that, like our 14. This might be the most naturally soft-flowing punchbowl Raynor ever created and quite possibly his deepest. Founded in 1892 as Fairfield County Golf Club, making it one of the oldest in America, the club subsequently changed its name to Greenwich Country Club then called in Seth Raynor to redesign the original 18-hole layout. The green complex and greenside bunkers were very similar to today’s, but again the fairway turf used to spill right into the bunkers. Below is a great example of how some of our green pads have shrunk over time. Making par on this hole 90 years ago, with the clubs and balls of the day, and with no trees to block wind, was quite a feat. This wasn’t for players hitting their shots on 16, but to punish longer hitters who challenged 15, as their balls would roll all the way into 16 pond. Some aspects have changed over time and some have stayed original for close to 100 years. The green complex and bunkers were almost the same as today. Unfortunately, many alterations to the layout have been made down the years, including a new millennium renovation, eroding much of the original architect’s work. After the clubhouse moved, the current #6 green was rebuilt to the West. But also notice that the putting-green height turf extends up the slope on the right, helping to feed balls down towards the pin. The aesthetics of this style of architecture creates problems with player’s confidence, club selection and narrows the window of error on all yardages of approach shots. Mountain Lake Golf Course. This page has covered a lot of information regarding what was originally designed by Seth Raynor in 1919. Landing zones, uneven lies, difficult angles into greens from wide shots and well placed bunkers were part of Raynor’s key  designs, not trees. There are a few issues with Midland’s Redan, some from evolution and, I believe, some from never being built to Raynor’s specifications. The back side of the bunker would have been pushed upward, creating a “wall” look from the tee box. Green expansion work that we’ve completed on holes 2, 9, 17 and 18 were done with sod cutters, physically removing the ridge of built-up sand. Raynor wanted to entice a player to play up the right side of the hole, and the left bunker-essentially a cross bunker-, probably served that purpose. Unfortunately, it was a stunner. The land is tilted from north to south, with shots played up the right side catching the hill and rolling down the hill. It’s land was full of native trees and the course was designed around them. Again, there was no rough in front of the bunker on the right side, and the fairway actually went in front of the bunker on the left. The fairway bunker on the left was at the base of the hill and probably had a very steep wall face. This isn’t possible now; as the surrounding neighborhoods were built up, more storm-drain water came onto the property, and that area now is very wet. First, and most obvious, is the lack of trees. When the rerouting took place, a new green was built in the 9 th ’s current location. This has taken place on most holes at Midland because of the evolution of maintenance practices, combined with a bunker restoration that put the edges of the bunkers too far from the green surfaces. However, Raynor’s swales were usually perpendicular to the line of play. Raynor designed the collar to go right to the down slope into bunkers and towards these steep fall-away slopes. Below is a copy of a Midland Hills scorecard from 1935. Read More >> Cross bunkers were used by many classic golf course architects, in some instances to fool the player with depth perception and club selection; in others, to make a player hit a different club off the tee or as a second shot. Formerly known as Bloomington Country Club, Minnesota Valley Country Club is the proud owner of a Seth Raynor course dating back to 1924 that features a selection of replica holes like the Redan 2nd, the Biarritz 7th and Eden 12th. This page is intended to go through Midland’s Hill’s original design, give background on its designer, Seth Raynor, and discuss interesting aspects of the original architecture and his Template holes. Next, notice the three other fairway bunkers, which have since been removed. Raynor often had several Punchbowls on his courses, ranging in size and depth. This might have been the widest landing zone on the entire course — again creating a great variety of ways to attack the hole. The top picture is how the green was designed and has stayed original, with the collar right on the edge of the slope. The left side of the hole has a bunker which extends out 1/4 to 1/2 way in front of the green, usually blocking the player’s view of that section of the green. Husband of Charlotte A. Carpenter, widow, whom he married on February 27, 1881 in Manorville, New York. He died in the prime of his career, at the age of 51. Unfortunately, we do not have ground photos of the Biarritz in its original form. Macdonald" and "Seth Raynor." It’s interesting to view how some hole’s yardages have/have not changed in almost 100 years. Look at the picture below and not how The Short is supposed to look and play. When the clubhouse moved to its current location, with the rerouting of holes and the creation of the driving range, this green complex was used as number 1, with the cross bunker being rebuilt in front. Over time, the green was pushed back and rebuilt in its current location and status. The tee box you play from now is farther back and slightly to the East of the original. Seth Raynor routed the holes the way he did for a reason, to see the fantastic piece of property that Midland sits upon and to take advantage of the prevailing winds. 4 Responses to “Seth Raynor: A Comprehensive List Of The Projects With Which He Was Associated”. 2) Ball placement on that side of the fairway was rewarded with a better angle into the green. Looking at such architecture from the fairway, it is unmistakable Raynor. The tee box now is back farther than originally but the landing zones are about the same. The tee box, although shaped differently, was very close to the same spot as today. Now look to the front of 16 pond and notice that the fairway for 16 went right up to the pond edge. Look at the width, especially the right side of the first half of the fairway. You can see that there was fairway-height turf between the left and right bunkers and the green, again to cause off-line balls to roll into the hazard. Our current 3, Now look at the back 9 and how wide the fairways were on the current 10, Next thing to look at is the clubhouse and the driving range. Notice the dark shading around the backside. The size of the cross bunker demanded the player’s attention. Due to his unfortunate early death, comprehensive records aren’t easily avaiable. The green surface itself should extend up the hillside on the right, to get balls rolling down the hill more consistently, so you could play your shot way up the hill and use the topography of the surround to bring it close to the pin. It looks as if there used to be a grass bunker on the right side. There are several things that stick out immediately when you compare the 1945 Seth Raynor course to what you play today. Our current 4. The current #4 green was then left and considered The Short. This resulted in endless options of how to play the hole off fairway-height turf, with no trees as part of the strategy. We’ve brought the green back out to restore the false front, but without some construction work (along with number 1) it will remain one of the holes that don’t resemble the rest of the course or the rest of Raynor’s work. Without dredging the pond left of 14 and 17 and being able to drain the water in those directions, the area right of 14 will always be wet and not sustainable for fairway. If a player drove it into this bunker, advancing the ball to the green was doubtful. The 12th hole today was the original 10th. Their 11th hole is also an Alps/Punchbowl and considered one of the greatest holes in golf. The “Father of Golf Architecture”, Charles Blair Macdonald and his associate, Seth Raynor, originally laid out the Mid Ocean Club course and it opened for play in 1924 adjacent to the Atlantic. The shape of the green used to be at a slight left-to-right angle, instead of the straight-on circle it is today. The original width of this hole gave players several ways to navigate to landing zones based on how far they hit it off the tee. Another aspect to note is the lack of rough between the bunker and the fairway/approach/collar, which feeds off-line shots into the hazard. First notice that you play over the bunker on the left side if you choose to challenge that side if there a pin position there. Over time, I will continue to add to this page regarding Midland and its classic design, Raynor, as well as his well respected work. Our current Short no longer has a backdrop of trees but the bunkering is lacking that bold unmistakable Seth Raynor designed look. Maybe the most important hole that was lost was the original #6, The Short. This hole is a Seth Raynor Alps and Punchbowl Template. Unfortunately, over time, this hole has changed dramatically, mostly because of the planting of trees on both sides and subsequent shrinking of the fairway. From the tee box, you stared down into a massive fairway bunker on the left, which came all the way out into the fairway. My theory is that Raynor’s construction crew didn’t get the grass line correct, and Raynor didn’t return until after the grow-in was complete. National Golf Links of America. NGLA’s  green complex is very similar to Midland’s in that if you hit the ball too far, the slope will take your ball all the way through to the back left and off the green. Seth Raynor used Walsh Lake to his advantage and wanted players to play around and visually appreciate it. This could have been in place of the bunker; that part is debatable. Raynor left the Oak tree grove up the right side; everything else was open. Again, I’m going to reference National Golf Links of America’s Redan, as it’s touted as the best in American golf. The Hotchkiss School is surrounded by its Seth Raynor-designed 9-hole golf course where in 1924 Raynor formed a friendship with English teacher Charles Banks that would later develop into a design partnership. Note the first fairway bunker on the left, one large and long bunker. Midland sits upon top of a hill that over looks downtown Minneapolis. Take a look at the East corner of Midland vs. Les Bolsted GC across the street in 1945. The 14th hole used to play as the 12th. The marks "The Cultural Landscape Foundation", "connecting people to places", "Landslide", "Pioneers of American Landscape Design", and "What's Out There" are registered trademarks of The Cultural Landscape Foundation®, The Cultural Landscape Foundation Announces Cornelia Hahn Oberlander Is the Namesake of the New International Landscape Architecture Prize, EXPLORE: The Cornelia Hahn Oberlander International Landscape Architecture Prize, Paul Goldberger on the Importance of the Prize, Nominee Qualifications, Jury Process and Governance.